Genealogy fraud

 

Currently at the Historical Society, I’m cataloging our collection of several hundred family histories in order to provider better access to our members and patrons.  In the course of the project, I noticed something interesting.  About twenty family histories were written by the same man, J. Montgomery Seaver.

Fraud001

Seaver’s photograph appears at the beginning of each book, along with a few pictures of illustrious members of the family.  These photographs are followed by “The Battle Hymn of the [family name].”  The lyrics to each one is a little different.

Fraud003 Fraud004

The main part of the book consists of lists of prominent people with the family name and genealogies that usually link the family to King Edward I of England or William the Conqueror.

Fraud002

In 1930, Seaver was charged with fraud by the Post Office Department.  Apparently, he picked 49 common last names (the “best” families, as he called them) and sent post cards to everyone in the phone book with those names.  The hardcover, cloth bound books cost $10.00 apiece.  We don’t know what happened to Seaver, he might have been convicted, acquitted, or bargained his way out.  His books are still widely cited by researchers, but here at HSMC, we’ve decided to put a disclaimer in the books about the suspected fraud.

It looks like Seaver was out to make money, but other frauds are caused by family legends or the honest hopes we all have to inherit a fortune.  A famous legend concerns Anneka Jans, an early settler in New Amsterdam.  This article from our archive tells of a family in Lansdale that claimed to be her descendants.

Fraud007

Many people claimed descent from Anneka Jans and sued in the hope of claiming part of a Manhattan real estate fortune.  The real Anneka Jans did own about 62 acres of modern Manhattan (though not the land Trinity Church is on), but she was not the granddaughter of a Dutch king (the Netherlands didn’t technically have kings in the 17th Century).  She was from what is today Norway.  A good account of the legend and facts can be found here.

Have you come across any hoaxes or frauds?  Have you discovered any family legends that turned out to be false?  Tell us about them in the comments section.

Advertisements